Monthly Archives: July 2010

So much for transparency…

In Delhi, after the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) reported scams worth 20 crore rupees in construction projects for the upcoming Commonwealth Games, the Delhi Chief Minister has passed a “gag order” on her colleagues in the cabinet to keep the … Continue reading

Posted in Delhi, Mumbai, Transparency, Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Mind your own business, Mr. Patil!

“Miffed at the way things have been handled by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) regarding the numerous potholes on city roads, Mumbai guardian minister Jayant Patil decided to take some officials concerned on ride in his car.” Continue reading

Posted in Governance, Local Government, Participatory Planning | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Air-conditioning in transit: A Third-World perspective

If air-conditioning is to be seen as only a culturally-induced necessity, then enforcing it on third-world countries seems to suggest a degree of cultural imperialism that should not go unchallenged. Indians live in a social environment that is vastly different from that of the West. Most commuters do not have air-conditioning either at home or at work – for many slum-dwellers, even an electricity connection is a luxury. They do try to alter their environments to help cope with the heat – common methods are to have high ceilings for better ventilation or to sprinklewater on the roof. But their methods remain ‘passive’, and still require a degree of adaptation by the human body. Continue reading

Posted in Air-conditioning, Bangalore, Mumbai, Needs of the poor, Planning in Context, urban heat islands | Tagged , , , | 15 Comments

Road widening and the structure of local governance

The constitution envisions a highly decentralized and democratic form of local governance, whereas current practice is quite autocratic and centralized. Bharatlal Meena’s attempts to thwart democracy are mere symptoms of a deeper malaise in the entire system of governance. Continue reading

Posted in Bangalore, Governance, Local Government, Metropolitan Government, Road Widening, Transportation Planning | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

What’s Mumbai been upto?

The past month seems to have been a busy month for transportation planners in Mumbai. Here’s a quick round up of what’s going on (with only limited commentary on my part). Continue reading

Posted in Airport, Environmental Assessment, Metro, Mumbai, Navi Mumbai, Park-n-ride, Sea-links, Skywalk, Suburban Rail, Transportation Planning, Water Transport | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Transportation in the United States: An open letter to the Chief Minister of Maharashtra

Mr. Chavan, USA is just beginning to realize that there are big flaws in the way it has planned its transportation infrastructure. These mistakes have resulted in huge petroleum imports that drain USA’s exchequer, in a greenhouse gas footprint that threatens the survival of the human species, in an infrastructure demand that helps no one but the contractors who build the infrastructure, and in the all-round destruction of America’s oldest cities. That is the “world-class” transportation infrastructure that you seek to emulate. Continue reading

Posted in Bike-renting, Bus Rapid Transit, Buses, Car-free streets, Congestion Taxes, Cycle lanes, Cycling needs, Equity in Planning, Footpaths, Governance, Highways, How do cities work?, Land-use Planning, Mumbai, Needs Assessment, Needs of the poor, Participatory Planning, Pedestrian Needs, Planning in Context, Suburban Rail, Suburbs, Transportation Planning, United States | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 50 Comments

We’re all Maldivians today

If the year 2009 could be changed, I would work towards strengthening President Nasheed’s hand in Copenhagen, for he does not represent Maldivian interests alone. If saving the planet is only in Maldives’ interests, then I say that we are all Maldivians today. And we must be ready to declare that for the purpose of climate change negotiations, President Nasheed will represent us instead of our national leaders. Continue reading

Posted in China, Climate Change, Governance, International Politics, Maldives, Mitigation | Tagged , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Book Review – Slumming India: A chronicle of slums and their saviours

Slumming India by Gita Dewan Verma is an attempt to make sense of some of the most baffling conflicts surrounding urban slums in the 1990s and early 2000s. In such issues, the maze of allegations and counter-allegations is incredibly deceptive, and even intelligent people are prone to losing track. Verma tries – and arguably succeeds – in untangling the strands and providing the reader with some clarity on the subject. Employing Orwellian satire and Chomskyian matter-of-factness in equal measure, Verma weaves an intricate pattern that explains how, despite more than half a century of planning in India, slums have thrived, feeding on the despair of their residents. Continue reading

Posted in Delhi, Equity in Planning, In situ development, Indore, Master Plans, Planning History, Sites and services model, Slums | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Ideology vs. Reality in Transportation

We need to leave ideology behind in order to study how cities really work. Nor can we find solutions at the extremes of laissez-faire or total state ownership. Rather, solutions will have to be found in the messy in-between where markets and governments work together to improve the lives of Delhi’s residents. Continue reading

Posted in Congestion Taxes, Delhi, Free markets, Gasoline Taxes, Induced Demand, Libertarianism, Licenses, Transportation Planning, Utopias | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Navi Mumbai: Retrofitting a “planned” city

In some sense, Navi Mumbai is just another suburb of Mumbai, but in some other ways, Navi Mumbai is the solution to Mumbai’s problems. Navi Mumbai has a mandate to attract persons from Mumbai and reduce the congestion and over-crowding there. But to achieve that, it needs to make the daily trip to work cheaper and less time-consuming. Continue reading

Posted in Bike-renting, Buses, Cycle lanes, Cycling needs, Navi Mumbai, Needs Assessment, Needs of the poor, New Towns, Parking, Transportation Planning | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments