Category Archives: Mumbai

Taming street-people: India’s grand civilizational project

A status message by a friend on Facebook has had me thinking for many weeks now. He wrote: Ranchi is an amazing city. In my first 30 minutes there, two schoolchildren, one bike rider and a goat tried to kill … Continue reading

Posted in Car-free streets, Equity in Planning, Indian National Movement, Mumbai, Planning History, Ranchi, Safety, Skywalk, social spaces, Street Vendors, Suburban Rail | Tagged , , | 13 Comments

Governmental “informality” in India

I referred, last week, to this paper by Ananya Roy which argues that informality and the collapse of rule of law in India is not a result of the disdain that ungovernable masses have for law, but a result of … Continue reading

Posted in commonwealth games, Delhi, Informality, Mumbai, Yamuna Floodplain | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

The benefits of being Obama

The latest news from Mumbai is that President Obama is about to visit, and all the routes he might possibly take are being beautified. Some of them are even being adorned with date palm trees, despite these trees being completely … Continue reading

Posted in Informality, Local Government, Mumbai, Street Vendors | Tagged , | 9 Comments

Ringroading and Mumbai’s spatial structure

Mumbai is currently undergoing historic but unnoticed changes that might possibly alter its urban structure beyond anyone’s imagination. It’s monocentric structure that aligned the entire city towards the downtown in South Bombay is likely to change very soon. Indeed, this … Continue reading

Posted in Airport, Highways, Land-use Planning, Metropolitan Government, Mumbai, Navi Mumbai, New Towns, Suburbs, Transportation Planning | Tagged , | 3 Comments

Parks vs. Parking: What do Indian cities need?

Chennai had prepared a plan some years ago for a multi-storey parking deckĀ  in T. Nagar where the Panagal Park now stands. T Nagar, once a quiet residential neighbourhood, is now the shopping centre for all of Chennai and has … Continue reading

Posted in Aizawl, Bangalore, Chennai, Delhi, Mumbai, Park-n-ride, Parking | Tagged , , , , , , | 7 Comments

Transit as a social space

In a previous post, I had argued that air-conditioning transit is a wasteful and avoidable expenditure that adds little to the comfort of the commuter, and that city planners should instead seek to reduce crowding in transit by increasing the … Continue reading

Posted in Mumbai, Needs of the poor, social spaces, Suburban Rail | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments

Metros and social justice: the case of Mumbai

Amitabh Bachchan, the famous Bollywood actor, recently stirred up a controversy when he complained in his blog about the intrusion of his privacy due to the construction of the Mumbai Metro near his mansion “Prateeksha” in Juhu. The city responded … Continue reading

Posted in Equity in Planning, Metro, Mumbai, Rehabilitation | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Vendors are the security, can’t you see?

Street vendors and homeless persons should be welcome on streets – between the two groups, they occupy the streets at all times of the day and night, providing stray walkers at night the security of not having to worry about being the only person on the street. And yet, we find that governments respond to their presence in exactly the opposite manner – Mumbai wants to get security to keep people from “encroaching” the elevated walkways when they could have gotten these “encroachers” to themselves serve as security – at so much less expense and freeing up so much time of the already overworked Mumbai Police. Continue reading

Posted in Bangalore, homeless persons, Mumbai, Needs of the poor, Pedestrian Needs, security, Skywalk, Street Vendors | Tagged , , | 4 Comments

Promises, promises…

My analysis of two news reports in Mumbai this week promising drivers of personal vehicles the opportunity to “zip over” congested roads. Continue reading

Posted in commonwealth games, Delhi, Highways, Induced Demand, Mumbai | Tagged , , , , | 6 Comments

So much for transparency…

In Delhi, after the Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) reported scams worth 20 crore rupees in construction projects for the upcoming Commonwealth Games, the Delhi Chief Minister has passed a “gag order” on her colleagues in the cabinet to keep the … Continue reading

Posted in Delhi, Mumbai, Transparency, Uncategorized | Tagged , | 1 Comment